Main content start
Initiative Event

Rethinking Comparison: Comparative Methodologies for Ancient History

Date
Fri April 16th - Sat April 17th 2027, All day
Location
Department of Classics
Building 110, Room 112
Event Organizer
Image caption:

A Renaissance reconstruction (1450–1475) of Ptolemy's 1st projection, indicating the Land of Silk in northeast Asia at the end of the Silk Road, and the land of the Qin in southeast Asia at the end of the maritime routes.

Overview

Comparative ancient history has become increasingly popular in recent decades, but the field remains undertheorized. Scholars routinely compare historical cases across cultures, time periods, and regions, yet they often diverge in their methodological assumptions and goals. This conference brings together scholars otherwise scattered across different fields to address one overarching question: how, exactly, do we compare historical cases properly and fruitfully? 

Initiative Event Information such as agenda, programs, or report
Event Agenda

Panels are organized around seven themes that recur most often in methodological debates about comparative history, where two contributors were invited to engage one of the seven themes to form a dialogue.

The Stakes of Comparison
The most frequently encountered question for comparative historians is not “how?” but “why?” What new knowledge does comparative history generate, and at what cost? Which comparative insights are specific to antiquity, and which are more generally relevant?

  • Lisa Raphals (University of California, Riverside)
  • Francesca Rochberg (University of California, Berkeley)

Commensurability
Commensurability between comparanda has long been debated by structuralist anthropologists, historians of science, and scholars of antiquity. These debates have probed the relationship between similarity and difference, and asked whether commensurability is a useful concept at all.

  • Shigehisa Kuriyama (Harvard University)
  • Reviel Netz (Stanford University)

Scale
Comparative cases can be drawn at virtually any scale, from a single text or an individual to a state, a culture, or even a hemisphere. This panels asks which tools suit which scales of comparison. 

  • Joseph Manning (Yale University)
  • Ian Morris (Stanford University)

Asymmetry in Sources and Expertise
Comparative cases are rarely evenly matched: the surviving evidence for one case may vastly outweigh that for another; and researchers may have expertise in one tradition but not in another. This panel addresses the challenges posed by these inevitable asymmetries.

  • Walter Scheidel (Stanford University)
  • Jingyi Jenny Zhao (University of Cambridge)

Center and Periphery
Comparative history tends to gravitate toward well-documented imperial cores, leaving provincial, nomadic, and subaltern cultures legible only as “peripheries” defined in relation to those centers. How can we compare “central” and “peripheral” cases? How does the framework of center and periphery affect our comparison?

  • Lane Fargher (Ohio State University)
  • Carolina López-Ruiz (University of Chicago)

Synchronicity
Comparative historians are naturally drawn to synchronous cases, such as the Roman and Han empires; yet some of the most productive comparisons cross barriers of time. This panel re-examines the historiographical assumptions underlying synchronous comparisons and asks what synchronicity implies for comparisons.

  • Peter Bang (University of Copenhagen)
  • Michael Puett (Harvard University)

Digital Humanities
Digital methods in the age of NLP and large language models make it possible to analyze unprecedentedly large bodies of evidence. This panel considers what tools, questions, and standards of review are appropriate for digital comparative ancient history. 

  • Giovanna Ceserani (Stanford University)
  • Jeffery Kotyk (Max Planck Institute for the History of Science)